While research is underway to determine the cause of Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD), pesticides have emerged as one of the prime suspects. Recent bans in Europe attest to the growing concerns surrounding pesticide use and honeybee decline.
Neonicotinoids are a relatively new class of insecticides that share a common mode of action that affect the central nervous system of insects, resulting in paralysis and death. They include imidacloprid, acetamiprid, clothianidin, dinotefuran, nithiazine, thiacloprid and thiamethoxam. According to the EPA, uncertainties have been identified since their initial registration regarding the potential environmental fate and effects of neonicotinoid pesticides, particularly as they relate to pollinators. Studies conducted in the late 1990s suggest that neonicotinic residues can accumulate in pollen and nectar of treated plants and represent a potential risk to pollinators.
There is major concern that neonicotinic pesticides may play a role in recent pollinator declines. Neonicotinods can also be persistent in the environment, and when used as seed treatments, translocate to residues in pollen and nectar of treated plants. The potential for these residues to affect bees and other pollinators remain uncertain. Despite these uncertainties, neonicotinoids are beginning to dominate the market place, putting pollinators at risk.
The case of the neonicotinoids exemplifies two critical problems with current registration procedures and risk assessment methods for pesticides: the reliance on industry-funded science that contradicts peer-reviewed studies and the insufficiency of current risk assessment procedures to account for sublethal effects of pesticides.
Imidacloprid has been scheduled for registration review, to be completed in 2016. According to EPA, the agency does not have adequate data to understand the potential exposure of imidacloprid to terrestrial invertebrates that may be exposed to imidacloprid through reliance on plant flower parts for habitat or diet. The agency is currently requesting field residue test data for imidacloprid residues in leaves, nectar and pollen.
Clothianidin is neurotoxic and is highly toxic to bees and other non-target insects. In 2008 a massive bee die-off occurred in Germany which was subsequently associated with clothianidin. Germany moved to ban clothianidin and other neonicotinoids pending further investigation. Clothianidin was given conditional registration in the US in 2003, without sufficient data to support its registration. Current data gaps include a lack of field tests for honeybees. A study, submitted in 2007 to EPA in support of this registration criteria, was recently deemed inadequate.
An internal EPA memo, leaked to the beekeeping community from an undisclosed source at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in December 2010, shines light on a key deficiency in the agency’s efforts to protect honeybees. The memo indicated that registration of clothianidin was unsound considering the study findings, and EPA was quietly re-evaluating its use, even as they planned future expansion. Beyond Pesticides and Pesticide Action Network North America (PANNA) wrote a letter to EPA following this leaked memo urging the agency to remove this pesticide from the market. Read EPA's official response to our letter, which rejects immediate action on removing this chemical which is toxic to bees. See also what the agency initially said to the press, and our chronology of events on clothianidin in response. Take Action: Tell EPA to protect pollinators and ban bee-killing pesticides. Submit a public comment and make your voice heard! Also, join our petition urging Congress to step up!
Studies implicating these pesticides in bee decline and CCD can be found in the Research webpage.